Book review: A Skeptic's Faith

Charles Siegel cannot accept religion by faith alone. Instead, in A Skeptic’s Faith, he puts religious belief to the test through scientific methods and philosophical ideas. He acknowledges that materialism can explain matter but not the mind-body connection, subjective experience, knowledge, or morality like dualism can.

Siegel challenges some traditional tenets of Christianity because they don’t scientifically hold up, like creationism versus evolution. However, he does find examples that suggest a higher consciousness exists, most notably in near-death experiences. Halfway through the book, Siegel concludes that “successful reconciliation of science and religion must be based on spiritual experience.”

The book's second half provides arguments against “prominent proponents of new atheism” who rely on materialism. Here, Siegel explains their major ideas and refutes them. But at the same time, he claims these writers are in denial, ignorant, dehumanizing, narrow-minded, bigoted. As readers, we don’t need Siegel’s judgments thrown at us—it actually weakens his own voice.

Curiously, Siegel’s book ends abruptly with the “Idealogues” section, giving the materialists the last word. Instead, he should have reiterated dualism as a better way to explore religion and faith.

Fortunately, you don’t need a degree in science or philosophy to follow Siegel’s reasoning, nor do you need to read the new atheism books he writes about to follow his counter-argument. This is a weighty book, containing nuggets that may resonate with skeptics and believers.

rating: ★★★★

A Skeptic's Faith: Why Scientific Materialism Cannot Be the Whole Truth
by Charles Siegel
Omo Press